Multifaceted Crisis

While it is premature to definitively predict the emergence of a civil conflict in Pakistan, the risk of further escalation cannot be discounted.

By Bisma Shaikh | October 2023

Pakistan, a nation with a population of approximately 241 million, currently grapples with a multifaceted crisis that has ignited widespread protests across the country. This unrest primarily emanates from the surge in electricity tariffs, a direct consequence of Pakistan’s earnest endeavours to secure a critical $3 billion bailout from the International Monetary Fund (IMF). The protests, occurring in various cities, give rise to apprehensions concerning Pakistan’s future prospects, encompassing issues of political instability, social unrest, and economic repercussions. The involvement of traders in these protests further compounds the situation, potentially disrupting markets and trade. It is imperative that underlying issues be addressed through constructive dialogue to mitigate the long-term ramifications of the ongoing crisis.

At the core of Pakistan’s present predicament lies a severe economic crisis, exemplified by an alarming inflation rate of approximately 29 percent, which poses a daunting challenge to the population’s livelihoods. To confront this crisis, Pakistan entered into a significant agreement with the IMF in July, which entailed the provision of a $3 billion bailout. While this accord was deemed vital for stabilizing Pakistan’s fragile economy, it came with a set of stringent conditions, including substantial reductions in energy subsidies. This, in turn, led to a substantial escalation in power tariffs, placing additional strain on households already grappling with financial hardship.

The decision to augment electricity prices was a necessary measure to meet the IMF’s stipulations and implement essential economic reforms. However, it has elicited widespread disapproval among Pakistan’s citizens, particularly those residing in poverty. The upsurge in electricity bills has emerged as a focal point for public frustration, culminating in nationwide protests. These protests, now extended to numerous urban centres, signify a growing disillusionment with the government’s economic policies.

The looming question pertains to the potential escalation of these protests into a civil conflict. While making precise predictions about the future remains challenging, several factors, as shown in the following, warrant careful consideration:

Government Response: The government’s approach to handling the protests will play a pivotal role in determining the outcome. An excessively forceful and repressive response could exacerbate tensions and lead to more extensive unrest.

Public Sentiment: The level of public support for the protests and the extent to which the populace is willing to endure hardship for their cause will be pivotal factors. Public sentiment can significantly influence the trajectory of protests, whether they remain peaceful demonstrations or escalate into violent confrontations.

Read More