New Delhi
Enemy’s Enemy
India’s foreign policy towards Taliban-led Afghanistan is a matter of great concern for Islamabad.
Before delving into the India’s inclination towards the current Taliban-led government in Afghanistan, let us have a brief look at the history. During the Cold War, the former Soviet Union (USSR) and the United States were trying to make alliances to strengthen and spread their global power.
Other than extending its power in the region, Soviet Union was also trying to extend its support to liberation and leftist movements internationally, e.g. the Chinese Communist Party, and the like. Likewise, the Cuban government, under the leadership of Fidel Castro, strengthened its relations with the USSR, while many Eastern European states also established the left governments with the help of the Soviet Union. Keeping up the momentum, Soviet forces also entered Afghanistan in 1979, which commonly is termed as the ‘Soviet Invasion of Afghanistan.’
However, the Soviet official narrative denies an ‘invasion’. During the early 1980s, the official Soviet media maintained that the Afghanistan Government had requested Soviet military assistance for humanitarian and non-combat tasks. In marked contrast, the critics believe that was the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, which ultimately led to the disintegration of the Soviet Union. According to an article by Rafael Reuveny and Aseem Prakash titled ‘The Afghanistan war and the breakdown of the Soviet Union’, published in the Review of International Studies, “The Afghanistan war accentuated the cleavages between the Russian republics and the Soviet state. It provided a common rallying banner for the secessionist movements and led to many anti-war demonstrations. In effect, it severely eroded the legitimacy of the Soviet system in the eyes of the non-Russian nationalities.”
It was not surprising for the world that the US, with the help of Pakistan, created Mujahideen to counter the Soviet Union and left Afghan people, after the withdrawal, at the mercy of the Taliban. Even the millions of Afghan migrants were not expatriated from Pakistan. Interestingly, the US needed Pakistan’s support after the 9/11 attacks. Now, once again America entered Afghanistan and remained there until its withdrawal in 2021, and this was surprising that in a very short span of time, the Taliban forces were able to capture Afghanistan. Since then, the situation has changed and till now most of the countries in the world are reluctant to recognize the Taliban regime, which has, time and again, given emphasis to their commitments with the international law, but to avail so far.
However, despite assurance from the Taliban government, the world is silently observing many mishaps happening in the war-torn Afghanistan. Against this backdrop, India had maintained cordial relations with the Ashraf Ghani regime. However, when the Taliban took over the country, it became a formidable challenge for India to continue its relationship with the Taliban regime.
It is interesting to note that despite terrorist attacks in different parts of India, still, the Indian authorities initiated their direct contact with the Taliban in 2013. India has been alleging Pakistan for every terrorist attack that happened in India. Since Pakistan shifted its policy towards the Taliban after 9/11, and later Abdul Ghani Baradar, the senior Taliban leader, was arrested by Pakistan in 2010, these developments further accelerated the mistrust between Taliban and the Pakistan authorities. In this connection, India issued a visa to a senior Taliban leader, Mullah Abdul Salam Zaeef, for attending a conference in 2013.
Zaeef, in his book titled “My Life with the Taliban”, criticized the Pakistan’s military establishment for its role in the exploitation of Taliban leadership. But, after the US withdrawal and the end of the presidential term of Ashraf Ghani, it became difficult for India to continue cordial relations with the new Afghan government led by the Taliban, since India had a fear that the Taliban would interfere in the India-occupied Kashmir. However, the Taliban government assured Indian authorities that they will not interfere in internal matters of India.
Still, according to senior Urdu journalist Hamid Mir, “India invested billions of dollars in Afghanistan after 9/11, even building a new parliament building in Kabul. India also built dams, roads, schools, universities, hospitals, and sports stadiums in different parts of the country. All this would go to waste if it didn’t engage with the Taliban”. Apart from different other reasons, this was one of the major reasons that compelled India to engage with the Taliban regime.
Despite assurance from the Taliban government, the world is silently observing many mishaps happening in the war-torn Afghanistan.
Recently, an Indian delegate led by JP Singh, who is joint secretary of Pakistan-Afghanistan at the Ministry of External Affairs, visited Afghanistan and held a meeting with Afghanistan’s Acting Foreign Minister Amir Khan Muttaqi. Although the Indian government’s narrative shows that the purpose behind holding this meeting was to extend Indian support to Afghanistan on humanitarian grounds. On the other hand, since Pakistan had disturbing relations with Afghanistan during the Ghani regime, it had also been accusing India to use Afghan soil against Pakistan. Yet, the Pakistani authorities showed concern about the Indian delegate’s current visit to Afghanistan by mentioning that “Pakistan has no problem with India establishing a relationship with the Taliban as long as it does not undermine the country’s interest”.
The situation has taken an interesting turn as the Taliban regime is assuring Indian authorities that they will not interfere in the India-occupied Kashmir. At the same time, the Taliban regime knows that maintaining good relations with Pakistan is important for their regime. Likewise, Pakistan also needs to keep good relations with the Taliban, so that they may not rely on India. Since Pakistan knows that the proscribed Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) has links with the Afghan Taliban, therefore, Afghan regime is not ready to take the TTP head-on because the Afghan Taliban fear that if the TTP is disowned by the Taliban, it may join Daesh.. In this regard, the Taliban regime tried to facilitate Pakistan and the TTP to hold talks in Kabul in 2022.
Though we cannot expect any positive change under the Taliban regime because their rule is not based on democratic norms, now it depends on the Taliban regime how it is able to convince the world community that they will obey the human rights, especially the rights of women and religious minorities.
The writer is currently serving as an Assistant Professor at the Faculty of Heritage, Aror University of Art, Architecture, Design & Heritage, Sukkur. He can be reached at qasim_shu2016@yahoo.com
Rehmat Ali Hasnie honoured as CEO of the year
Total PARCO organizes university day
Supreme Court rejects review plea in One Constitution Avenue case
Time for Animal Liberation
Islamic banks to encourage start-ups, generate jobs
‘I want to be healed,’ says model Saheefa Jabbar
India’s wrestling chief charged with harassment
HBL launch a customer care Twitter handle
Jubilee Life sends-off Pakistan’s contingent to Special Olympics
Pakistan Welcomes New British Envoys
Policy dialogue on Menstrual Health & Hygiene Tax Reforms held
Heart of Stone trailer is out
Xi, Blinken agree to Stabilize U.s.-China
India struggles with sweltering heat wave
Nepal bans Indian film
Naimal Khawar faces criticism for alleged plastic surgery
Son builds Taj Mahal for his mother
Naseeruddin shah apologies to Sindhi-speaking people
Leave a Reply