Cover Story
Mohajir Forever!
The Urdu-speaking Indian Muslims who had migrated to East Pakistan in the 1940s are still looking for a place of safety for their coming generations.
Well before the 1947 Partition of the Indian subcontinent, Muslims in Bihar and UP states of India in particular were being seen as the unwanted minority in India because of their boisterous support for a Muslim homeland. In both UP and Bihar, at least 10 major Hindu-Muslim riots took place from 1929 to 1938. In one of the most vicious riots in Bihar in October 1946, Hindu mobs targeted Muslim families in much larger numbers killing thousands. Ostensibly, that riot was in response to riots in Noakhali against the Hindus, which in turn was instigated by the great riots of Calcutta where thousands of Muslims were killed.
The continuous wave of anti-Muslim riots in Calcutta, UP and Bihar hastened the exodus of Muslims from areas which were to become India. Their flight continued into the late 1950s as intermittent rioting resumed, particularly in Bihar years after the Partition. In the greatest migration of human history which accompanied the partition of India, nearly 15.5 million people were forced to flee their homes and around 1.5 million people died in the bloodletting, hunger and exhaustion. While accurate data has not been compiled, out of the total 15.5 million refugees, the total number crossing over to India was estimated at around 8.5 million and those moving to East and West Pakistan were estimated at around 7 million.
Many refugees from Bihar and UP may have preferred to go to West Pakistan in 1947, but the killings at the western border or proximity to East Pakistan for some, resulted in people like my parents travelling to the Eastern part of Pakistan. Nearly two million immigrants arrived in the newly-formed province of East Pakistan, replacing around one million Hindus who migrated to India from that province. Based on the subsequent census of 1951, it is believed that around 60% of the Muslims arriving in East Pakistan were Bengalis from West Bengal, Assam, etc. The remaining 40% were Urdu-speaking people, a majority of whom came from riot-torn Bihar, while others from various parts of India, such as UP, CP, etc. Gradually, the new Urdu-speaking residents of East Pakistan, regardless of which part of India they came from, began to be collectively known as ‘Biharis’, since the majority of them were immigrants from the Indian state of Bihar.
Many of these refugees were employees of the railways, civil servants or factory workers. All those skills were badly needed in what was the agricultural hinterland of East Pakistan. The newcomers were warmly welcomed by Bengali leaders such as Huseyn Shaheed Suhrawardy and Fazle Haq, etc., who were rumoured to have orchestrated the reaction of the Muslims to the riots in Calcutta, encouraging them to move to East Pakistan. The icing on the cake was the lot of Muslim businessmen (Adamjees, Bawanis, Isphahanis, Hasans, etc.) who left Calcutta and Rangoon and arrived in Dhaka, Chittagong and Khulna to set up industries in East Pakistan.
The first two decades in the promised land was marked by remarkable stability and improvement in the socio-economic conditions of the newcomers from India. However, the fruits of economic growth were yet to make any significant improvement in the lives of ordinary Bengalis. The initial goodwill between the locals and the newcomers started to fall apart by the late 1960s. By 1969, a palpable feeling of uneasiness between the two communities had already set in. However, since the memories of the joint struggle for a Muslim homeland by the Bengalis along with the newcomers were still fresh in many minds, no one foresaw what was about to happen.
The inordinate delay in Yahya’s decision to convene the national assembly after Sheikh Mujibur Rahman won the elections (in December 1970) served to convince many Bengalis that they would never get their legitimate rights and began to become restless and furious. While Bhutto and Mujib’s brinkmanship risked the very integrity of Pakistan, it was also playing with the lives of the Urdu-speaking community, which was bound to become collateral damage if East Pakistan descended into chaos and civil strife.
India was delighted at the rupture of relationship between the two units of Pakistan and did all it could to actively encourage the fissure. India strengthened the hands of the Bengali separatists, aided them in targeting the minority Urdu-speaking community, which was seen as a symbol of federation. They even staged a plane high-jacking to gain pretext to ban overflights, cutting off the supply lines between East Pakistan and West Pakistan. There are many theories of how the Pakistani rulers fell into the trap carefully laid by India, but that is a subject of another discussion.
Around the 4th or 5th of March 1971, BBC reported the arrival of fresh troops to Dhaka. The Bihari population watched in horror and disbelief as they braced for the full fury of the vigilantes. Many Urdu-speaking people in East Pakistan fled their homes and took refuge near the cantonment areas. Houses in those localities were flooded with relatives and friends from other parts of the city squatting on the verandas, backyards, and in the servant quarters. The lucky few who could afford to buy a ticket to safety fled to West Pakistan. With only one flight per day, the price of a one-way ticket to Karachi, normally 250 rupees, shot up to several thousand on the black market.
The Bengalis had not forgotten that only a few months earlier (in August 1970), these Biharis were proudly flying the Pakistani flag on Independence Day. The Awami Leaguers knew that the Urdu-speaking community had always supported the federation and as such, they would always be against the creation of Bangladesh. The League’s leadership prepared to conduct the final act of ethnic cleansing of the abandoned, defenceless Biharis. The consistent pattern of killing in the smaller towns and villages only served to confirm that the massacre of the Biharis could not have been a spontaneous outburst of Bengalis angered by the ill-advised army action on March 25, 1971. It had the hallmarks of an organized genocide that could only have been conceived well in advance.
It is estimated that over 250,000 Urdu-speaking people were killed by the Bengali nationalists. Unknown number fled to adjoining countries and to Pakistan in 1971. Around 270,000 were repatriated to Pakistan and some 200,000 mainly women and children ended up in Red Cross camps. Their children and grandchildren numbering around 250,000 (80% born after 1971) still live in subhuman conditions in about 116 camps around Bangladesh.
The Urdu-speaking Indian Muslims who had migrated to East Pakistan are still looking for a place of safety for their coming generations. Even after 74 years since Pakistan’s independence and 50 years since the fall of Dhaka, the descendants of those who arrived in Pakistan are still labelled as ‘Mohajirs’. Their blood was spilled at the time of creation of Pakistan in 1947 and then again in 1971, when they had stood up for the integrity of the country in East Pakistan. Unfortunately, the divisive politics has not been conducive for them to feel at home in what is left of Pakistan. Constantly on the move for three generations since 1947, many have emigrated out of Pakistan for greener pastures and many more are desperate to leave legally or illegally. Their search for a home will only end when the label ‘Mohajir’ ceases to identify them and when they find places of safety for themselves and their children.
Based in Canada, the writer is a retired banker and consultant. He has written a personal memoir ‘Refugee: Unsettled as I Roam: My Endless Search for a Home.’ He can be reached at azmatashraf@hotmail.com
Excellent article. My family was lucky that we migrated to West Pakistan in 1947 but i know numerous families who came from east Pakistan to Pakistan post 1971 and their ordeals. the biggest losers of partition were the minorities left out in India and Pakistan esp urdu speaking Muslims who despite having their own culture were not in majority anywhere to secure themselves. hence have become permanent muhajirs