Born To Be Hanged

Zulfikar Ali Bhutto was a self-centred politician and had a severe lack of sense of human dignity and values of other people. His ruthlessness, capacity for ill-doing and many other personal traits destined him to be hanged one day.

By Kunwar Muhammd Dilshad | February 2020

Sir Maurice James the British High Commissioner to Pakistan from 1962 to 1965 had this to say about Bhutto:

"Bhutto certainly had the right qualities for reaching the heights--drive, charm, imagination, a quick and penetrating mind, zest for life, eloquence, energy, a strong constitution, a sense of humor, and a thick skin. Such a blend is rare anywhere, and Bhutto deserved his swift rise to power.......But there was -- how shall I put it? A rank odour of hellfire about him. It was a case of ‘corrupto optimi pessima’. He was a Lucifer, a flawed angel.

“I believe that at heart he lacked a sense of dignity and value of other people; his own self was what counted. I sensed in him a ruthlessness and capacity for ill-doing which went far beyond what is natural. Except at university abroad, he was surrounded by mediocrities, and all his life, for want of competition, his triumphs came too easily for his own good. Lacking humility, he thus came to believe himself infallible, even when yawning gaps his own experience (e.g. of military matters) laid him – as over the 1965 war – wide open to disastrous error.

“Despite his gifts, I judged that one day Bhutto would destroy himself -- when, I could not tell. In 1965, I so reported in one of my dispatches from Pakistan as British High Commissioner. I wrote by way of clinching the point that ‘Bhutto was born to be hanged.’ I did not intend this comment as a precise prophecy of what was going to happen to him, but fourteen years later that was what it turned out to be. “Man proposes, God disposes. His hanging may not have been for the alleged murder but he deserved to die for his role in the breakup of Pakistan.”

The first quality Bhutto sought amongst his minions was obsequiousness and ruthlessness on his behalf. For instance, J.A. Rahim, who was one of his mentors and was much older in age, was stripped, defiled and tortured along with his son in prison. Bhutto expected people to arrive punctually at his functions. I was at one where we were all seated waiting for him for two and a half hours. I got up to help myself to get a drink and was warned by Yahyah Bakhtiar not to do so. Nor we were even allowed to use the washroom. At a certain function J.A. Rahim said that he was tired of waiting for the Maharaja of Larkana and stormed out. Bhutto then sent Saeed Ahmed his chief of security to beat up Rahim and his son and then dispatched to the tender mercies of Jam Sadiq Ali where they were kept naked together in the same cell, tortured and their bodies defiled.

According to Brian Cloughley in his book about Pakistan titled ‘War, Coups and Terror,’ “Over the years the political scene under Bhutto resembled that at the court of a particularly paranoid and malevolent Kabuli chieftain”.

ZAB asked Mustafa Khar to recommend the most depraved man he knew in the civil service to be DC Larkana to ‘fix’ his opponents; Mustafa Khar who later fell out with Bhutto recommended Khalid Kharal.

Then came the elections and Khalid Kharal told ‘sahib’ that as he was so busy there so no need for him to conduct an election campaign in Larkana and would remove his opponent Jan Muhammad Abbasi of the Jamat-e-Islami so that he could be elected unopposed. There was absolutely no reason to do this. Bhutto was so popular that Jan Muhammad Abbasi would have lost his deposit. As things happened, Bhutto was elected unopposed and the bureaucracy thought that this is what ‘sahib’ wanted. In addition to that, all the other Peoples Party chief ministers were also elected unopposed. Why Bhutto whom everybody thought to have enormous political sense agreed to Kharal’s proposal is beyond me. The election lost all credibility, resulting in continuous social turmoil which Bhutto was unable to put down even by declaring partial martial law in some cities. Two Brigadiers resigned in Lahore rather than order their troops to fire on the protestors and particularly in the Punjab when asked to do so their officers found that they were firing in the air as there was no relationship whatsoever to the number of rounds fired and the casualties.

Then Bhutto went on to choose his own hangman by appointing Genreal Ziaul Haq as chief of army staff. Zia was the 6th junior most amongst the Lieutenant Generals. There are numerous stories about his obsequiousness before Bhutto. There is one I know for certain which is that when Bhutto visited Multan, Zia, who was corps commander, asked all the officers’ wives and families to stand outside their houses and shower rose petals on Bhutto’s cavalcade.

These two decisions by the ‘politically brilliant Bhutto’ led to Sir Maurice James prediction that ‘Bhutto was born to be hanged’ come true.

The fates saw to it that three main persons who were responsible for the tragedy of East Pakistan met a violent end. Indira Gandhi was gunned down by her own Sikh bodyguards, Mujib by killed his own army in his house and most agonizing of all was that of Bhutto who waited for months on a death row and had to be carried in a stretcher to the gallows in April 1979. The jailor Chaudhry Yar Muhammad said that this was not unusual the only exception being the religious fanatic who would kiss the rope before his execution. Who knew 40 years ago that it was now common for suicide bombers to kill themselves and others in a mistaken belief of their faith?

The writer is a former Federal Secretary of the Election Commission of Pakistan. He can be reached at
kmdilshad@hotmail.com

Submit your Blog
Cover Story
Interview
News Buzz

Leave a Reply

Update